Filter by: Products Articles
Filter by:

Mail Bag - Too Much Spanking

By Michael Pearl


[intro music]

Debi Pearl:  Pop and I are going to record, so you all go ahead and shut the door.

Child 1:  Are they recording about naughty children in there?

Child 2:  I don't know..

Announcer:  Have you ever felt like you might be spanking too much? This week, in our Vintage Answers series, Mike and Debi offer some practical advice.

Michael Pearl:  OK.

Debi Pearl:  OK, here's another letter. This one's kind of long. It says, "Dear Mr. and Mrs. Pearl, I have recently read your newsletter for June and July, of which I am a new subscriber. Contained in the letter was an article named, "It's The Book's Fault". I read the article with great interest. I truly relate to the mother who wrote to you. I, too, am frustrated. Unfortunately, I could have written parts of the letter to you. When I read your response, I cried like a little child. I cried for my flops and my failures, and I cried for the other woman who wrote to you. She must still be picking herself up off the floor. I read your book, "To Train Up A Child", which I found very educational and full of wisdom. The woman also read your book. She has similar problems as I do. I have four children, ages nine, seven, six, and four: three boys and a girl, in that order. They argue, fight over toys, get into things they shouldn't: they get into flour, and Daddy's tools, and pens and markers, and eggs and potatoes, and you name it, they get into it.

They still need to be spanked to go to sleep. They still throw an occasional fit. They have bad attitudes, and my seven year old is starting to lose control of his temper...a lot. My daughter screams, and pinches, and scratches her seven year old and six year old brothers. My seven and six year olds scream when they are going to get a whipping, or even they throw a fit. Yes, they get spanked for all these things: screaming or fit‑pitching. Sometimes, I wonder if it makes any difference, because they're not learning from all the spankings, they just keep doing all these things.

My nine year old dawdles a lot, has trouble focusing on what I ask him to do. He says he forgets. I wondered about spanking for forgetting, it's a daily habit. Forgive me for being critical of my children, but I'd rather have the bad news come first, so we can deal with it. I do love my family, I love my children dearly. I want to train them in the way they should go. And yes, I have my own vision of what I want my children to be like, and I don't want to blame your book.

I had these problems before I read it. Some days, obviously, are better than other days. Some days, I just sit and cry. I do have a different twist, in that my husband does not approve of spanking the children. He yells, and yells, and yells. Therefore, my spanking hours are limited. I'm even unsure of his salvation. I'm not a perfect Christian, but I'm not the same person I was nine years ago, when I first got saved.

I do not have a role model to follow, and I'm not an outgoing personality. I have gone to our pastor for help, but he feels the kids are just bored. If only you could help me train, educate, and direct the children, or maybe direct me. But I know that's not possible. I guess I'm looking for specific answers to specific problems. How do I stop my seven year old from losing his temper and throwing a fit? Or smart‑mouthing me? How do I stop a lot of these things? I know you can't answer all my questions, but I'll pray you can help me."

Michael:  Alright. That's a almost seems impossible, when you hear a letter like that. We get quite a few letters like that. It seems just like the woman needs a thousand answers to a thousand problems, and to organize all the answers, to know what to do in each given situation, seems to be an impossibility. But let me say this: if I could take your children in my home, in three days, they'd all be obedient. In ten days, they'd all be happy, cheerful, joyful, and there'd be no problem at all. The problem here is really not one with the children. You know, it's not like you have bad kids; it's not like the kids are such a terror that they're in an impossible situation. The problem, obviously, is with the entire structure of the family. The mother and the father's relationship is important. Obviously, the mother doesn't have an authority in this family, she's not in control.

Sounds to me like she's close to nervous breakdown, and these are the kinds of situations that would create nervous breakdowns. Quite often, divorces come out of homes like this, so it's a very urgent situation, one that needs attention right away.

You need to look at the whole of what we've said in our books. When your pastor says that your children are probably just bored, we've said over and over again that one of the big problems in homes, especially homes where there's homeschooling, where the children are kept at home all day long is boredom.

And boys, especially, by the time they get six or seven years old, need to be outdoors. They need to be climbing and wrestling and working and playing hard. And they don't need to be cooped up with girls. They don't need to be put in a situation where they have to be quiet or where they have to be still. Boys need to be turned loose to be boys.

And you take a lot of children of different ages and put them in a family. Why, if you were to take eight pastors, six or eight pastors or six or eight psychologists or six or eight social workers and put them all in a room and make them stay all day long. And just give them a few toys to play with and then tell them to be good and be sweet, why, by the end of the day, they'd be fighting, they'd be fussing.

They'd be grouped into small groups, adversarial groups, and they'd be set one against the other. If you kept them there for weeks or months on end, then you'd have social problems. It's the same thing with children. You just can't cram children into a home and then try to order it so that there's quiet and order without giving them some outlet, some vent. So, yes, I think boredom's a big part of it.

But there's certainly a lack of respect, there's a lack of authority in the home. The mother must assume some authority, she must have some dignity. She must have some joy, she must make a statement and then stand behind it.
You just need to go back and look at the whole of what we've said and establish a relationship with your children that's one of love, one of imagination, one of expression, one of security, one of fun, one of joy, excitement about doing things, accomplishing things, doing things together. And in the midst of that, they won't have the time to stop and be rebellious and be angry towards one another.

I would say this on the spanking. When spanking is not working, in other words, if you're employing the rod and you feel like you're doing it too much, you feel like it's ineffective, then probably you are doing it too much. If using the rod is ineffective, then don't just keep using it.

In other words, if all you're doing is creating anger and resentment and you're upset, the children are upset. Then, there are other elements involved. Spanking is not the whole. In other words, you can't throw the whole of the child training or discipline into the spanking. If you are relying on that alone, and other things are not equal, then it will not work and it can become abusive.

Back off and say, "What am I missing here? Am I establishing fellowship with my children? Am I being consistent?" If you are inconsistent, you will spank your children too much. If you are inconsistent, then your children are not going to be learning, they are not going to develop any discipline or any consistent habits.

They are going to continue their sloppy habits. You will spank them again and again for the same thing, for one reason, you are not consistent. If the spanking is not working, ask yourself the question, "What am I doing wrong? What other elements am I missing?"

Debi:  One point that you might try, that we get a lot of letters from parents that say every evening when the children are put to bed, they put on our tapes, "No Greater Joy." The volume set of tapes, and the children enjoy listening to stories about other children and how the discipline made them a better child. The parents say it's amazing how to fix their own children. Their own children get a certain pride in being a better child after listening to how bad the other children are, they don't want to be like the other children. So that's an idea to start training them.

Michael:  Yes. We get letters from people and we've talked with individuals where they said that their own children, seven, eight, nine years old begin to assume some authority in the home over the younger children or even or their peers, siblings that are older. In other words, they would say to mama, "Mama he is doing this or that. Don't you think that he needs a spanking?" Or "Mama, she is doing this or that. Don't you think needs to do?" Then the child will quote something from our book, and refer the mother to it.

Children are pretty sharp. They are pretty keen. They are good psychologists. They will make some observations about their own behavior and the behavior of others around them. They will appreciate what you are doing then, they will understand why you are doing it.

They will see the necessity of it. They will even remind you some time when they have been disobedient of some of the principals or guidelines. They will develop insights, so it is really valuable to include your children, if not in listening to our tapes. Then in discussions about the why and wherefore.

When our children were younger, especially, we went through he books op proverbs with them. We'd let them read verses. We would discuss wisdom. They developed a lot insight into what God required if what was ideal in our relationship to our fellow man and our relationship to each other in the family.

Nurture your children and train them with admonishing. Whatever tool that might require, whether it's scripture, listening to our tapes, discussions or some materials you get somewhere else.

Announcer:  Thanks for listening; I hope it blesses your day. Don't forget to check out Cane Creek Corner for this week's specials.

[outro music]

Leave a Reply

4 comments on “Mail Bag - Too Much Spanking”

  1. I have 7 children and homeschool. I have had to think out of the box to keep the kids entertained. They now are loving running through corn fields with whistles and flags just playing tag. Its been a blast. I find things for them to do outside, like pulling weeds, carrying baskets of laundry and vegetables for me. It works they feel like they accomplish something and they love being Mommy's strong men. I saw a neighbor getting ready to burn some odds and end of wood. So I asked him if my boys could have it. Once he said yes I sent the boys over to ask, of course they did not know that I asked already. They came running back all excited. I said ok if he said you can have go get it all. Off with the wagons and wheel barrels. They build and take apart all day long. Now one thing I learned some 10 years ago was that when I was ready for bed , often they were not. So we came up with a rule that they did not have to sleep but they had to lay in their bed, no books, only one stuffed animal. They could sing quietly or listen to the bible or soft Christian music, usually they would drift off in 15 min. It saved on a lot of upset by not telling them they had to go to sleep. I have not had one issue with them going to bed since we started this 10 yrs ago. I would love to share more but its late and I must go to bed. Be blessed.

  2. That was really good! I think tonight I will let my boys 12 and 8 listen "To Train Up a Child" tape. It is true about letting them outside to burn up their energy. My children (unfortunately) go to public school, but my husband (praise God) let's me homeschool during the summer. We only do it for 1 hour, M-F, just to learn what they are NOT getting in school. My youngest is very ACTIVE! It does help when he can go outside and play! I also find when they have a project to do, that they have chosen, they argue less and are more pleasant. I am praying and asking the LORD for wisdom and guidance. He is faithful!!!!
    Thank you Mr. and Mrs. Pearl for the great advice.

  3. This momma has forgot rule #1, Breaking their will! This first step is ever so important. The children NEED to know you are in control. They won't trust you untill you prove that you are reliable on your word. You do not need to spank for this, but it is much faster. I used push ups for my older boy. He would not stop mouthing off, so I ordered him to do push ups 15 at a time untill he stopped talking back. He did 95 before he stopped. I babysit all the "problem" children noone else will. Toddlers who won't go to bed when told need to be held down untill they submit! If it takes you 4 hours, to just hold them. NO YELLING NO ANGER NO VOILENCE just holding firm but gentley. THIS WORKS! Then show them love at every oppertunity. People's so called bad children are a wonderful blessing in my home & after the first time of disobedience they never do it agian. They love & respect me as well because I treat them with love & respect!
    P.S. A child should NEVER get away with smart talking back. That is the first sign of disrespect & rebelion. It will EXPLODE from there! My family has been blessed by train up a child. My house & life was a nightmare, see above story. Now my home is the sweetest place to be & my children, all 5 are a joy!

  4. Thank you Michael & Debbie. Another excellent subject. It must be very painful for this mother to publicly speak of her struggle. We mothers want to be so good at this role and we often fall short. Thankfully we can fall upon God's love and His strength. Your good advice fits there as well.