If your dad says okay, and your mom says okay, then I would wear very little cover up, and modest mascara. Stick with natural hews, like nudes and browns for eye shadow. Eye liner, is for nighttime, and you do not need to be going out at nighttime =). I am not saying this out of a spiritual conviction, but a conviction with fashion. When models are not in a specific make up for a shoot, they usually stick with an all natural look. Even most fashion shoots have natural looking makeup. There are some great brands that are less harmful to the skin like Mychelle. Also, lipstick, is dated, except for a particular event, usually night. Stick with natural lip color, and put on chap stick or a subtle gloss. Most guys like a natural face. I’d say most people find a natural looking made up face looks clean but not inappropriate. Sometimes, I think religious conservatives go to an extreme by not taking care of themselves at all, and look like dirty people and tired. Keep in mind, when you are married, do as your husband should wish. Shoshanna Easling wears makeup, and she looks natural and beautiful.